Let’s face
it. Aren’t we all a little bit pleasure-seaking? It satisfies us however other
people are being exposed or expose theirselves, how they live their lives. We
want to know how they handle sometimes ridiculous, sometimes serious issues.
What do they do in their free time, what jobs do they have and how’s their
family situation? Are they single, divorced, famous, beautiful, ugly, happy? We
want to know everything about anyboy.
In reality
shows we bet on people to win, we vote for them according to how far they go,
how much they can stand no matter how absurd, risible, stupid or unscalable the
task they have to manage is.
So how far away is our media world from the one in the Hunger Games? What differs us from the audience and the people there?
To answer
this questions, I would like to compare the “Hunger Games” with “I’m a celeb,
get me out of here!”.
- The tributes/candidates
Junglecamp
- 10 candidates
- celebrities who volunteer for
the show (can give up at all times by saying "I'm a celeb, get me out of here")
- 18+
Hunger Games
- 24 tributes
- unvoluntarily chosen (volunteering
possible)
- some trained their whole lifes
for this challenge (secretly), some thrown into the arena completely
unprepared
- aged between 12-18
- The challenge
Junglecamp
- collect stars to get food and
luxury goods
- convince the audience to vote for your win by managing disgusting and dangerous tasks
Hunger Games
- convince the sponsors to get
you necessary goods like medicine, food, water etc.
- kill your opponents to be the
last standing tribute for winning the Games
- The prize
Junglecamp
- people get payed for their
participation
- they get a bonus if they win
- (extra) publicity
Hunger Games
- improvement of their living
conditions
- money, fame, honor
- no more worries
- The intention of the show
Junglecamp
- entertainment
- amusement
Hunger
Games
- reminder of the Capitols power
- keep the people in the Capitol satisfied by entertaining them
- keep the district people under
control (they can’t do anything against the governments decisions)
- punish the residents for their
uprisings (things that happended long before they were even born)
- The price
Junglecamp
- loss of privacy
- reputation (because the show is
intellectually undemanding)
- dignity
Hunger Games
- psychic trauma
- emotional distress
- life
If you read
the above comparisons you become aware of how much we have in common with the
people in Panem. We accept the violation of other peoples minds and lives just
to be entertained. We make them do things they don’t want to do.
“We are different: We don’t force people to
kill each other! People volunteer for going to the junglecamp to earn money and
publicity!”
So don’t
some of the kids volunteer? They sign up for tesserae to facilitate their
families a better life, accepting that their names will be in the reapingbox
more often and the chance of being chosen increases. They try to win in the arena
to make a better life for their loved ones possible. It’s their intention to
improve the image of their family in their district and whole Panem, not mainly
but in some kind. Like the people in the junglecamp they wanna earn something,
not lose.
The biggest
differences between the two shows are that the candidates in the camp are
adults. who are there by choice, not kids, who are chosen without their
acceptance, like the tributes in the Hunger Games.
But how
long does it take until the attraction of todays tv shows dwindles away, until
someone comes up with the idea to force people to do things like this in
punishment? For example, that criminals have to fight against each other until
death and the winner regains his freedom and independence. Just for entertainment.
Live. 24 hours, 7 days a week. Will we watch?
How far
will people go to be entertained, to forget their own problems, to flee from
reality?
Will they
be able to distinguish reality from the illusory world anymore?
And who
will be untroubled by this shows, no matter whether as spectator or candidate?
We will
know soon.
Let me know
what you think about this comparison and how far people will go,
AA
"I'm a celeb, get me out of here" challenge
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T2mW5TNaevA
"The Hunger Games" final challenge
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UZ1R8QH1Nuc
(I'm sorry you can't klick on the links. Just copy them into your browser.)
(I'm sorry you can't klick on the links. Just copy them into your browser.)
Hey AA!
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion your point of view is very clear.
You listed many facts about the shows and I really like that.
Your post is very long and I'm very sad that this is your last one!
ZZG
DF